Understanding the Unexpected Resilience of Fish in the Face of Marine Heatwaves

Marine heatwaves have long been considered a potential threat to the delicate balance of ocean ecosystems. Prolonged periods of unusually warm ocean temperatures can wreak havoc, causing damage to coral reefs, harming seabird populations, and triggering harmful algal blooms. However, a recent study, titled “Marine heatwaves are not a dominant driver of change in demersal fishes,” published on August 30, 2023, in the journal Nature, challenges our assumptions about the impact of these heatwaves on fish.

Unveiling Surprising Insights

While the destructive effects of marine heatwaves on various marine life forms have been well-documented, their impact on fish has remained relatively unexplored. Researchers from Canada, Europe, and the United States collaborated on a comprehensive study that yielded unexpected results: fish are remarkably resilient to the challenges posed by marine heatwaves.

A Global Effort

This groundbreaking study, which involved experts from multiple countries, aimed to provide a comprehensive understanding of how marine heatwaves affect fish populations. Titled “Marine heatwaves are not a dominant driver of change in demersal fishes,” the research was published in the prestigious journal Nature on August 30, 2023.

Data-Driven Analysis

To unravel the mysteries of fish resilience in the face of marine heatwaves, the researchers utilized extensive data collected from scientific trawl surveys conducted between 1993 and 2019 in continental shelf ecosystems across North America and Europe. These surveys involved towing nets above the seafloor to assess the abundance of species on the ocean’s bottom. Impressively, the analysis included data from 248 marine heatwaves characterized by extreme sea bottom temperatures.

“The Blob” Incident

The researchers didn’t stop at analyzing historical data; they also examined a notable event known as “The Blob.” This warm water anomaly struck the Pacific Ocean off the coast of North America from 2014 to 2016, capturing the attention of scientists worldwide. The study specifically explored how The Blob affected populations of demersal fish, including species crucial to some of the world’s largest fisheries, such as Alaskan pollock and Atlantic cod.

Unexpected Findings

What sets this study apart is its surprising revelation: there is limited evidence to suggest that marine heatwaves have a significant and widespread impact on regional fish communities. While some marine heatwaves did lead to declines in fish biomass, these instances were found to be exceptions rather than the rule. The researchers discovered that, in many cases, the effects of marine heatwaves closely resembled the natural variability observed in these ecosystems.

A Glimpse of Ocean Resilience

Lead author Alexa Fredston, assistant professor of ocean sciences at the University of California, Santa Cruz, emphasized the emerging notion that the oceans possess a degree of resilience. Fredston noted, “While oceans are changing in response to climate change, we don’t see evidence that marine heatwaves are wiping out fisheries.” This observation highlights the adaptability of fish populations in temperate oceans.

Variability in Ocean Environments

It’s important to recognize the inherent variability of both ocean conditions and fish populations. Against this backdrop of natural variability, the researchers failed to uncover compelling evidence that marine heatwaves dramatically reduced fish abundance in temperate oceans.

Localized Effects of Marine Heatwaves

While the study paints a picture of overall fish resilience, it also acknowledges the localized impact of marine heatwaves. These events can drive changes at a local scale. It’s worth noting that numerous marine heatwaves have occurred with no lasting consequences, further underscoring the complex and dynamic nature of our oceans.

A Quest for Consistency

In addition to exploring the impact on fish abundance, the researchers investigated whether marine heatwaves were altering the composition of fish communities. They sought signs of losses among cold-water species and an increase in warm-water species, a phenomenon known as “tropicalisation.” Surprisingly, they found no consistent signature for such changes caused by marine heatwaves.

Contrasting Results

These findings stand in stark contrast to earlier studies, as co-author William Cheung, a professor at the University of British Columbia Institute for Oceans and Fisheries, pointed out. Cheung’s previous research had projected significant negative impacts on fish catches due to heatwaves and climate change. However, this study suggests that the effects of marine heatwaves on fish populations are sporadic and not as uniform as previously believed.

In conclusion, this study challenges our preconceptions about the vulnerability of fish to marine heatwaves. It sheds light on the complex and variable nature of ocean ecosystems, where resilience and adaptability play a crucial role in safeguarding fish populations.

Source: Read more